SEQR Categorical Exclusions: Economics but Environmental Justice?

Last week I attended the annual ALI-CLE Environmental Law conference in Washington, D.C., as a law student guest. The almost two and half days of lectures were educational, interesting and hopeful for aspiring environmental lawyers-to-be.

One of the many topics discussed was about Environmental Justice. The three speakers were members of the U.S. E.P.A., the D.O.J.’s Natural Resources and Environmental Division, and the N.Y.S. Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC). The DEC agent spoke of the requirements of the State Environmental Quality Review (SEQR). What struck me was not that he mentioned that SEQR is sometimes criticized as “job-killing” or “prohibitory on development,” but rather a push by the DEC to expand Title II categorical exemptions in urban areas.

The speaker discussed how the DEC wished to streamline the process of approval of developing abandoned/unused land in cities, especially paved spaces. By allowing such development to proceed without undergoing to the long process of an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS), urban areas can be improved or expanded much quicker. It makes smart economic sense.

However, this push runs into environmental justice problems. Quick development does not necessarily take into consideration the desires or best interests of current residents in a neighborhood. True, turning an unused paved surface is a better use of land than leaving it as is; but turning it into overpriced residential units or into inaccessible office buildings might damage the sense of community and price out the current residents.

New York’s Environmental Conservation Law 1-0101, the statutory authority for SEQR, includes as part of New York’s environmental policy the declaration that the State shall “conserve, improve and protect … in order to enhance the health, safety and welfare of the people of the state and their overall economic and social well being” (emphasis added). Moreover, subsection (3)(b) states that “future and present generations” shall be “[g]uarantee[d] that the widest range of beneficial uses of the environment is attained without risk to health or safety, unnecessary degradation or otherwise undesirable or unintended consequences” (emphasis added).

Thus, in laying out the State’s policy, the legislature directed the DEC and all state agencies to take a holistic approach and consider all the effects of a proposed action. Allowing more Title II categorical exemptions in the name of urban development might have benefits for some, but environmental justice consequences for others. Creating environmental justice consequences runs counter to the State’s environmental policy and contributes to the continuation of practices that give the word “justice” to “environmental justice.”

181 Comments on “SEQR Categorical Exclusions: Economics but Environmental Justice?

  1. Pingback: ユナイテッドアローズ モンクレール

  2. Pingback: gucci 通販

  3. Pingback: wow gold

  4. Pingback: asics gel 33 2.0

  5. Pingback: mens new balance 373

  6. Pingback: ladies asics shoes

  7. Pingback: new balance kids runners

  8. Pingback: new balance 992 men

  9. Pingback: asics supreme lyteflex

  10. Pingback: asics 2000 series

  11. Pingback: Anonymous

  12. Pingback: best asic running shoes for men

  13. Pingback: asics gel kayano women

  14. Pingback: new balance malaysia online

  15. Pingback: new balance classic 990

  16. Pingback: asics gel kayano 17 men

  17. Pingback: new balance sneaker ml574

  18. Pingback: new balance m574 black leather

  19. Pingback: asics gel sneakers

  20. Pingback: new balance sneakers for women sale

  21. Pingback: new balance 1400 japan

  22. Pingback: asics gel kayano 18

  23. Pingback: saucony asics running shoes

  24. Pingback: new balance 420 blau

  25. Pingback: lolo jones asics

  26. Pingback: asic shoes for women

  27. Pingback: asic gel nimbus 14 womens

  28. Pingback: black new balance trainers

  29. Pingback: 三陽 バーバリー コート メンズ ブラック

  30. Pingback: asics tiger black

  31. Pingback: asic tiger

  32. Pingback: new balance cleats

  33. Pingback: asics womens wide width

  34. Pingback: buy new balance 420 online

  35. Pingback: asics gel kinsei 3 mens

  36. Pingback: are new balance shoes good

  37. Pingback: バーバリー レディース トレンチコート サイズ表

  38. Pingback: new balance 991 offerta

  39. Pingback: asics review

  40. Pingback: new balance 574 trainers sale

  41. Pingback: デパート バーバリー トレンチコート 価格

  42. Pingback: asics gel kayano pink

  43. Pingback: new balance grey and pink

  44. Pingback: asic kayanos

  45. Pingback: バーバリーロンドン フード 発売

  46. Pingback: FFXIV Gil

  47. Pingback: wildstar gold

  48. Pingback: diablo 3

  49. Pingback: wildstar gameplay guide

  50. Pingback: new balance careers

  51. Pingback: Anonymous

  52. Pingback: cheap new balance shoes

  53. Pingback: new balance574

  54. Pingback: new balance mr1400

  55. Pingback: Anonymous

  56. Pingback: new balance 610

  57. Pingback: asics 2170

  58. Pingback: new balance 574 green

  59. Pingback: new balance minimus womens

  60. Pingback: asics gt 2000

  61. Pingback: new balance shoes for men

  62. Pingback: asics volleyball shoes

  63. Pingback: asics gel nimbus 14 womens

  64. Pingback: new balance sale

  65. Pingback: asics onitsuka

  66. Pingback: asic running shoes

  67. Pingback: jordan 4 oreo

  68. Pingback: legend blue 11s

  69. Pingback: oreo 4s

  70. Pingback: zapatos new balance

  71. Pingback: asics shoes

  72. Pingback: Anonymous

  73. Pingback: Anonymous

  74. Pingback: asics running

  75. Pingback: asics gel scram

  76. Pingback: asics gt 2170

  77. Pingback: asics noosa

  78. Pingback: new balance 623

  79. Pingback: bottega veneta

  80. Pingback: buy jorans

  81. Pingback: Celine UK

  82. Pingback: asics womens shoes

  83. Pingback: new balance retro

  84. Pingback: air max pas cher

  85. Pingback: new balance sneakers

  86. Pingback: Anonymous

  87. Pingback: asics 2160

  88. Pingback: asics aggressor

  89. Pingback: new balance mr1400

  90. Pingback: new balance mr1400

  91. Pingback: Anonymous

  92. Pingback: asic bitcoin

  93. Pingback: new balance 990

  94. Pingback: asics kayano

  95. Pingback: new balance 860

  96. Pingback: asics sneakers

  97. Pingback: asics running

  98. Pingback: asics mens running shoes

  99. Pingback: new balance boots

  100. Pingback: asics golf shoes

  101. Pingback: asics gel blur 33

  102. Pingback: new balance sko

  103. Pingback: new balance sneakers

  104. Pingback: new balance 1080 v4

  105. Pingback: asics womens running shoes

  106. Pingback: Anonymous

  107. Pingback: new balance philippines

  108. Pingback: asic running shoes

  109. Pingback: asics noosa tri 8

  110. Pingback: new balance enfant

  111. Pingback: asics gel lyte 3

  112. Pingback: asics gel noosa

  113. Pingback: new balance 991

  114. Pingback: new balance 812

  115. Pingback: new balance 1400

  116. Pingback: new balance skor

  117. Pingback: new balance 620

  118. Pingback: new balance kids shoes

  119. Pingback: jordan 11 legend blue

  120. Pingback: Bulls Over Broadway 10s

  121. Pingback: new balance 850

  122. Pingback: Gucci Replica Cheap Handbags

  123. Pingback: シャネル カメリア ネックレス

  124. Pingback: Basketnike Air Max Femme Pas Cher

  125. Pingback: Coach Factory Outlet Sales

  126. Pingback: replica hermes uk

  127. Pingback: Air max Pas Cher Avis

  128. Pingback: new balance 500

  129. Pingback: Portefeuille Longchamps Pas Cher

  130. Pingback: new balance 990v3

  131. Pingback: Air Max Rose Pas Cher

  132. Pingback: new balance 860

  133. Pingback: new balance black

  134. Pingback: new balance cleats

  135. Pingback: buy replica bags uk

  136. Pingback: Pliage Longchamps Pas Cher

  137. Pingback: jordan 4 oreo

  138. Pingback: asics gt 2000 review

  139. Pingback: asics gel beyond

  140. Pingback: asics noosa tri 8

  141. Pingback: asics walking shoes

  142. Pingback: new balance turf shoes

  143. Pingback: asics noosa tri 8

  144. Pingback: new balance minimus 20v3

  145. Pingback: new balance 1080v4

  146. Pingback: asics gel noosa tri

  147. Pingback: asics patriot

  148. Pingback: asics gt 2170

  149. Pingback: new balance running

  150. Pingback: asic bitcoin

  151. Pingback: asics tennis shoes

  152. Pingback: asics gt

  153. Pingback: new balance 608

  154. Pingback: new balance 574 women

  155. Pingback: new balance 860

  156. Pingback: asics logo

  157. Pingback: asics gt2000

  158. Pingback: asics gel cumulus

  159. Pingback: new balance mens shoes

  160. Pingback: asics runners

  161. Pingback: asics gel nimbus 15 review

  162. Pingback: asics women

  163. Pingback: Anonymous

  164. Pingback: Women's Pump Shoes

  165. Pingback: asics womens shoes

  166. Pingback: new balance 710

  167. Pingback: new balance wiki

  168. Pingback: asics gel lyte33

  169. Pingback: asic gel

  170. Pingback: asics runners

  171. Pingback: new balance enfant

  172. Pingback: Anonymous

  173. Pingback: asics gel blur 33

  174. Pingback: asics trail shoes

  175. Pingback: new balance skate shoes

  176. Pingback: womens asics running shoes

  177. Pingback: Anonymous

  178. Pingback: asics 2000

  179. Pingback: asics duomax

  180. Pingback: cheap nike shoes

  181. Pingback: guild wars 2 gold